Gender Gap among Math High Achievers Evident by Grade 9, Just Gets Wider

Gender Gap among Math High Achievers Evident by Grade 9, Just Gets Wider 

Every year several hundred thousand students from 6,000 schools participate in the American Mathematics Competitions (AMC), a program by the Mathematical Association of America that helps teachers identify talent in math among their students and to foster a love of math. The results of that "friendly" competition provided the data for a research project to understand the dynamics of the gender gap in high school math achievement. (AMC is also delivered in middle school, but for this project, the focus was on students in secondary schools.) According to a working paper recently published by the National Bureau of Economic Research, "a clear gender gap" among high-achieving students has already shown up by ninth grade, and it just widens through the remainder of the high school years.

The percentage of female students by grade and achievement level. Source: "Dynamics of the Gender Gap in High Math Achievement," from NBER

The percentage of female students by grade and achievement level. Source: "Dynamics of the Gender Gap in High Math Achievement," from NBER

The AMC contests are 25-question, multiple-choice tests designed to identify students working at high performance levels. Those who fall into that category tend to take the test year over year through their high school career. The AMC contest has multiple stages. By hitting a threshold score, students move into additional exams. Researchers Glenn Ellison, a professor in MIT's Department of Economics, and Ashley Swanson, an assistant professor of healthcare management in the Wharton School at the University of Pennsylvania, examined AMC data from 1999 to 2007.

They found that girls made up an ever-declining share of the top achievers with every passing year of high school. For example, among the top 5,000 students, female students made up 30.5 percent in grade 9, 26 percent in grade 10, 24 percent in grade 11 and 22 percent in grade 12. By grade 12, females made up just 7 percent of the top 100 students. The largest change occurred between grades 9 and 10, but it was a "fairly steady process clearly visible in every year."

The research also discovered that high-achieving girls improved by less on average from year to year than boys did with similar performance levels in the first year.

The researchers cautioned that the "widening gender gap" was "clearly a multifaceted phenomenon with several contributing factors." For instance, there could be gender differences in the decision to participate in competitions in the first place. And the "discouragement effect" could play a role. The report cited a 2012 study that found female participants in a TV game show tended to earn less than male contestants and to "exit the game prematurely at a faster rate." Other research found that while men who lose a contest react by "seeking greater challenges," women will react by "ceasing to compete." While many male students may respond to disappointment by "redoubling" their efforts next time, female students may more commonly just opt out of participation in future years. Girls are more likely than boys to cease participating in the AMCs when they experience a disappointing outcome; and even those girls with scores just below the cutoff will be 5 percentage points less likely to participate in the following year than girls who barely hit it.

The complete results of the working paper in digital form are available for $5 on the NBER website.

About the Author

Dian Schaffhauser is a former senior contributing editor for 1105 Media's education publications THE Journal, Campus Technology and Spaces4Learning.

Featured

  • split-screen digital illustration of two AI-influenced classrooms

    What AI Gets Right and How It Will Be Used in the Year Ahead

    AI has tremendous potential to do good in education while honoring and upholding the essential role of teachers. However, its success will depend on how we choose to use it.

  • DreamBox Math

    Discovery Education Announces Updates to Experience, DreamBox Math

    K-12 learning solution provider Discovery Education has announced enhancements to its Discovery Education Experience and DreamBox Math products, designed to create a more personalized, engaging learning experience for students.

  • The AI Show

    Register for Free to Attend the World's Greatest Show for All Things AI in EDU

    The AI Show @ ASU+GSV, held April 5–7, 2025, at the San Diego Convention Center, is a free event designed to help educators, students, and parents navigate AI's role in education. Featuring hands-on workshops, AI-powered networking, live demos from 125+ EdTech exhibitors, and keynote speakers like Colin Kaepernick and Stevie Van Zandt, the event offers practical insights into AI-driven teaching, learning, and career opportunities. Attendees will gain actionable strategies to integrate AI into classrooms while exploring innovations that promote equity, accessibility, and student success.

  • A geometric pattern of open Chromebook computers with bold outlines, subtle shading, and soft gradients, spaced evenly with vibrant green and blue accents on a neutral background.

    Challenges and Opportunities Ahead for the 'Great Chromebook Refresh'

    During the pandemic, the education community scrambled to provide students with laptops to promote online learning equity and mitigate learning loss. Today, those devices are approaching the end of their useful lives — and a "great Chromebook refresh" has been predicted as schools seek to replace them with newer models.