Surviving the Media’s War on Educational Technology

 


Can we keep ‘techno-skepticism’ from the mainstream?

By Geoffrey H. Fletcher, Editor-at-Large

Ouch! The back-to-school press coverage has been less than complimentary of technology in education, at least according to my high-level scan of the news in early September. Numerous newspaper and magazine articles and editorials have taken shots at the use of technology in education and the money spent on it. Two recent examples:

  • The Sept. 10 issue of the Seattle Post-Intelligencer carried an article by AP technology writer Greg Sandoval in its Business section titled,“Gadgets Can Overload Students.” The article, targeting parents, cited a student who would rather go to a library than use the Web, and quoted experts saying that technology often ends up being a distraction.
  • The Sept. 14 issue of The Atlanta Journal-Constitution ran the staff-written editorial, “Online Courses Just Haven’t Clicked” (www.ajc.com/opinion/content/opinion/0905/14edonline.html). Just one quote from this opinion piece will give you an understanding of their position, if the title did not already:“Many districts have squandered millions of dollars on computers that went underused and irrelevant software sold to them by aggressive vendors. Despite the rush to get the Internet into every US classroom, no one has proved that connected students become better students.”

But the mainstream press is not the only place where technology is taking a hit. For instance, in the September issue of the respected professional educator journal Phi Delta Kappan, the title of its occasional “In Canada” column is “Black Magic.” The author, Heather-Jane Robertson, writes that we may “have been following a false prophet,” and technology may be “a really bad idea.” Robertson g'es on to say that “techno-skepticism is on the brink of going mainstream.” The example she gives is a cover story that ran in Canada’s most widely read English-language newsmagazine, Maclean’s, titled “How Computers Make Our Kids Stupid” (Sue Ferguson, 2005, www.macleans.ca/topstories/education/article.jsp?content=20050606_106930_106930).

So, what are we “true believers” to do? Here are a few suggestions:

Understand the arguments of the “techno-skeptics” and learn from them. We have not always been clear about why we are using technology in education, and our planning has not always been perfect. In addition, we have not paid enough attention to the people expected to implement the technology and the impact on the overall school culture in doing so. We are getting better at this, but we need to do even more.

Make clear what success with technology is, and get your success stories out into the public. We need to change the question and perspective from which the techno-skeptics seem to operate: D'es technology work, or is it worth it? Instead, we need to ask: Under what conditions d'es technology __________? Then we fill in the blank with various purposes. These purposes could be to raise student achievement, improve attendance, become proficient in using tools of the 21st century, etc. Just as there is more to education than raising test scores, there is also more to using technology than raising test scores.

Getting some positive stories in the local press would be a good idea as well. Don’t be afraid to call your local newspaper. They have space that needs filling every day, and stories about what kids are doing in the schools can be appealing to a large number of readers. Of course, don’t forget to let us in on the news, too: Write to us at [email protected]

Featured

  • cloud icon with a padlock overlay set against a digital background featuring binary code and network nodes

    Cloud Security Auditing Tool Uses AI to Validate Providers' Security Assessments

    The Cloud Security Alliance has unveiled a new artificial intelligence-powered system that automates the validation of cloud service providers' (CSPs) security assessments, aiming to improve transparency and trust across the cloud computing landscape.

  • robot brain with various technology and business icons

    Google Cloud Study: Early Agentic AI Adopters See Better ROI

    Google Cloud has released its second annual ROI of AI study, finding that 52% of enterprise organizations now deploy AI agents in production environments. The comprehensive survey of 3,466 senior leaders across 24 countries highlights the emergence of a distinct group of "agentic AI early adopters" who are achieving measurably higher returns on their AI investments.

  • laptop with a neural network image, surrounded by books, notebooks, a magnifying glass, a pencil cup, and a desk lamp

    D2L Updates Lumi with Personalized Study Supports

    Learning platform D2L has introduced new artificial intelligence features for D2L Lumi that help provide more personalized study supports for students.

  • cloud with binary code and technology imagery

    Hybrid and AI Expansion Outpacing Cloud Security

    A survey from the Cloud Security Alliance and Tenable finds that rapid adoption of hybrid, multi-cloud and AI systems is outpacing the security measures meant to protect them, leaving organizations exposed to preventable breaches and identity-related risks.