FCC Broadband Plan Draws Critics

In a statement yesterday, FCC Chairman Julius Genachowski announced the expansion of the Universal Service Fund's Lifeline program to include broadband internet access for low-income, disadvantaged, and rural Americans. However, in response, the Civil and Human Rights Coalition expressed concern with the program's timeline and cost-controlling measures.

Previously, the program only provided these groups with discounted phone service, either wired or wireless. In the statement, Genachowski indicated that broadband "has gone from being a luxury to a necessity in the 21st century," noting that internet access and digital literacy skills have become critical for job seekers.

Along with a number of reforms aimed at increasing the program's efficiency, Genachowski's new order would also set a budget for Lifeline to help "eliminate unnecessary spending" and root out waste.  

"We strongly support the announcement of sensible steps to eliminate fraud," said Wade Henderson, president and CEO of The Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights as part of the Civil and Human Rights Coalition statement. "However, the Chairman also announced he is moving ahead with a preemptive budget controlling costs for the program, even though the agency is still evaluating how the program could best be updated for modern technology and needs."

According to FCC data, the Lifeline program has about 10 million participants, and only reaches about 32 percent of eligible households. There are 100 million people in the United States who do not subscribe to broadband at home.

"We are gratified to hear the Chairman clearly state that the Lifeline program is poised to support high-speed internet broadband services," said Henderson. "The Chairman’s plan to modernize Lifeline to include broadband is an important first step toward achieving this goal, but we are concerned that it puts the program years away from having a notable impact on narrowing the digital divide. The pilot programs the Chairman intends to launch later in the year won’t help the millions of Americans struggling right now to get a leg up in today’s economy." 

About the Author

Stephen Noonoo is an education technology journalist based in Los Angeles. He is on Twitter @stephenoonoo.

Featured

  • elementary school boy using a laptop with a glowing digital brain above his head and circuit lines extending outward

    The Brain Drain: How Overreliance on AI May Erode Creativity and Critical Thinking

    Just as sedentary lifestyles have reshaped our physical health, our dependence on AI, algorithms, and digital tools is reshaping how we think, and the effects aren't always positive.

  • robot brain with various technology and business icons

    Google Cloud Study: Early Agentic AI Adopters See Better ROI

    Google Cloud has released its second annual ROI of AI study, finding that 52% of enterprise organizations now deploy AI agents in production environments. The comprehensive survey of 3,466 senior leaders across 24 countries highlights the emergence of a distinct group of "agentic AI early adopters" who are achieving measurably higher returns on their AI investments.

  • tutor and student working together at a laptop

    You've Paid for Tutoring. Here's How to Make Sure It Works.

    As districts and states nationwide invest in tutoring, it remains one of the best tools in our educational toolkit, yielding positive impacts on student learning at scale. But to maximize return on investment, both financially and academically, we must focus on improving implementation.

  • blue and green network lines

    HPE Intros Agentic AI Enhancements to Mist Platform

    HPE recently introduced new capabilities for its Juniper Mist platform that leverage agentic AI to enable more autonomous, intelligent, and proactive network operations.