The Role of AI in Assisting Teachers and in Formative Assessments of Students

How can AI be developed to help advance teaching? For beginners, it needs to put teachers front and center, according to a new report from the United States Department of Education.

The recently released report, “Artificial Intelligence and the Future of Teaching and Learning: Insights and Recommendations,” by ED's Office of Educational Technology (OET), outlines the opportunities, challenges, and risks of using AI in teaching and assessments. It offers recommendations for how these can be successfully fielded.

The report notes that the use of AI in teaching should “always center educators” (ACE) so that the answer to the question of whether AI will replace teachers is a resounding “no.” Teachers need to be involved with decisions about the design, selection, and evaluation of AI-enabled technologies. They spend about 50 hours a week, less than half that time directly involved with students, the report notes. AI can change that, taking over some of the administrative, clerical, planning, preparation, and evaluation tasks.

Some of the ways AI can assist and lighten teachers’ workloads include:

  • Helping adapt the standardized curriculum to better fit specific student or class needs;

  • Providing voice assistance to students with disabilities such as hearing impairment to translate American Sign Language into English;

  • Noticing and communicating patterns in student performance to target areas where they might need extra help.

But in order for teachers to help design, select, and evaluate AI tools, they need “time and support so they can stay abreast of both the well-known and the newer issues that are arising” to anticipate risks, the report warns. Questions such as when teachers should be at the helm, how much can be delegated to an AI, and how teachers can override the AI and regain control if needed should be addressed early on.

Other risks involve the danger of surveillance resulting in negative consequences for teachers and the possible difficulty in balancing how far to trust an AI. A chilling example is a study in which researchers found that “people will follow instructions from a robot during a simulated fire emergency even when (a) they are told the robot is broken and (b) the advice is obviously wrong.”

The report recommends that teachers be able to understand how an AI model works in order to make an informed decision about using, modifying, or overriding it, especially when the AI is making recommendations for individual student instruction.

This speaks to formative assessments and how AI conducts them. A key priority is to keep humans “in the loop and in control,” the report states. Such assessments go beyond mere grading. They involve using different question types to demonstrate student knowledge, measuring student skills beyond subject matter, giving real-time feedback, helping neurodiverse students demonstrate competencies, adaptating to differing learner abilities, assessing the learning process, and documenting ongoing progress as opposed to only achieved milestones.

AI-enhanced formative assessments can be done successfully using aids such as game format or reading aloud. Instant “feedback loops” of various kinds can be valuable, whether students are working alone, in small groups, or in a classroom.

The report’s recommendations for AI involvement with formative assessments include:

  • Measuring what matters, not only academics but other skills for success in life;

  • Supporting “help-seeking and help-giving” and detecting when those are needed;

  • Having teachers and students participate in assessment design and efficacy;

  • Monitoring for “algorithmic discrimination” in instructional interventions and support.

A webinar going into more depth on this report will be held Tuesday, June 13, 2023, at 2:30 p.m. ET. Signup is available by QR code at this link.

Visit this page for a summary handout of the report’s main points.

The full report can be downloaded from this page.

About the Author

Kate Lucariello is a former newspaper editor, EAST Lab high school teacher and college English teacher.

Featured

  • A teacher and students gather around a glowing crystal ball containing a miniature school building surrounded by clear AI symbols, including holographic interfaces, neural networks, circuits, and data streams

    2025 Predictions: AI's Impact on Education

    What should schools and districts expect from the evolving landscape of artificial intelligence in the coming year? Here's what the experts told us.

  • digital illustration of Estonia with glowing neural network-like connections spreading across the map

    Estonia to Roll Out ChatGPT Edu for all Secondary Schools

    In a nationwide artificial intelligence program dubbed "AI Leap 2025," the country of Estonia plans to provide free access to leading AI applications for all secondary school students and teachers. The initiative will launch with a rollout of ChatGPT Edu to 20,000 high school students in grades 10-11 and their 3,000 teachers, beginning Sept. 1.

  • A middle school student wearing safety goggles and a lab coat uses a microscope in a science lab, surrounded by beakers and test tubes filled with colorful liquids

    2025 Young Scientist Challenge Seeks Students Using Science to Solve Everyday Problems

    The entry period is now open for the 2025 3M Young Scientist Challenge, a science competition from 3M and Discovery Education for students in grades 5-8 recognizing individuals across the United States who have "demonstrated a passion for using science to solve everyday problems and improve the world around them."

  • young child sitting at a table, using a tablet with an AI-generated interface

    Research: 1 in 3 Kids Use AI for Learning

    In a survey of parents with children aged 8 or younger, nearly a third of respondents (29%) said their child has used AI for school-related learning, according to a new report from Common Sense Media.