E-Rate Begins at Home

This article originally appeared in T.H.E. Journal's September 2013 digital edition.

If we know anything at all about the impact of technology on learning, we know that students must be able to use it when they need it, as long as they need it. Studies from Project RED and other research initiatives have shown that ubiquitous access is a necessary (although certainly not sufficient) condition for technology to have a positive impact on student learning outcomes and behaviors. Hence, the move by so many districts toward a 1-to-1 computing ratio. 

But here’s the not-so-secret secret about 1-to-1 access: anytime and anywhere doesn’t just mean during the school day. For technology to have its truest impact, students need to be able to do research, use productivity tools, get instruction, engage with text, and practice skills (remedial or otherwise) at home too. And as more and more of these educational resources become web- or cloud-based, the need for sufficient bandwidth at home becomes the final, and critical, frontier in learning connectivity. 

Which is why the reformation of the E-rate is so urgently needed. The original E-rate mandate was created over 15 years ago—when there was no such thing as a smartphone and AOL defined online access. So if for no other reason, the program needs a makeover. 

But the E-rate needs to rethink what “equitable access” means. As computing devices get more and more affordable, and as schools commit to making sure every child has access to a learning device, equitability becomes less about the gadget and more about connectivity. And equitable connectivity becomes less about school and more about home. 

One key section in the proposed E-rate overhaul asks if the FCC “should permit schools to provide wireless hotspots to surrounding communities using E-rate supported services.” The answer to that should be a resounding “Yes!” (Or, if you are Homer Simpson, “D'oh!”) But wireless “hotspots” are not enough. Unless those community centers are a safe walking distance from every students’ home, opened early and closed late, and provide adult supervision, we are still looking at serious inequitable access to digital learning resources. 

I’d like to see the E-rate extend discounts to families in schools’ catchment areas, perhaps using qualifiers like those who are free or reduced lunch. (I’d also like to see the E-rate program ensure schools get those discounts. As CoSN director Keith Krueger notes, there has been little transparency on the requirement to give schools the lowest rate.) If families can’t afford their cable or teleco rates, then there is no home access. And learning begins at home, now more than ever.

About the Author

Therese Mageau is the former editorial director of THE Journal and Campus Technology. She can be reached at [email protected].

Featured

  •  classroom scene with students gathered around a laptop showing a virtual tour interface

    Discovery Education Announces Spring Lineup of Free Virtual Field Trips

    This Spring, Discovery Education is collaborating with partners such as Warner Bros., DC Comics, National Science Foundation, NBA, and more to present a series of free virtual field trips for K-12 students.

  • glowing padlock shape integrated into a network of interconnected neon-blue lines and digital nodes, set against a soft, blurred geometric background

    3 in 4 Administrators Expect a Security Incident to Impact Their School This Year

    In an annual survey from education identity platform Clever, 74% of administrators admitted that they believe a security incident is likely to impact their school system in the coming year. That's up from 71% who said the same last year.

  • horizontal stack of U.S. dollar bills breaking in half

    ED Abruptly Cancels ESSER Funding Extensions

    The Department of Education has moved to close the door on COVID relief funding for schools, declaring that "extending deadlines for COVID-related grants, which are in fact taxpayer funds, years after the COVID pandemic ended is not consistent with the Department’s priorities and thus not a worthwhile exercise of its discretion."

  • pattern of icons for math and reading, including a pi symbol, calculator, and open book

    HMH Launches Personalized Path Solution

    Adaptive learning company HMH has introduced HMH Personalized Path, a K-8 ELA and math product that combines intervention curriculum, adaptive practice, and assessment for students of all achievement levels.