Survey: AI Low on Superintendents' Priority List as Districts Face Challenges

  • By Kate Lucariello
  • 02/26/24

In education consulting company EAB's 2024 "The Voice of the Superintendent" survey, while superintendents agree that adopting AI is important, non-academic challenges make it a low priority.

The online survey, which ran from Nov. 27, 2023, to Jan. 10, 2024, was completed by 148 superintendents in 39 states. Of those completing, 70% had been in their jobs from one to 10 years. The majority of district makeup was suburban (52%) and rural (37%).

The survey reported an increase in superintendent job satisfaction, with a 9% increase in those planning to stay in their jobs over the next two years, despite exhaustion and burnout.

While 97% of superintendents feel schools should implement and teach the responsible use of AI in their classrooms, only 37% currently have a plan to do so. For the rest, non-academic challenges are making it nearly impossible.

Superintendents reported these major challenges have either stayed the same or increased since 2023:

  • Chronic student absenteeism, cited by 63% of respondents;
  • Disruptive student behaviors, 77%;
  • Worsening student mental health, 76%, with 77% of superintendents blaming social media (These first three challenges have been prevalent regardless of student socioeconomic status, results show.);
  • Chronic staff absenteeism, 51% instructional, and 52% non instructional (with working conditions to blame); and
  • Staffing shortages, i.e., open positions, 52% instructional and 66% non instructional.

The survey concludes with three major recommendations for addressing these issues:

  • Build a leadership team to identify solutions and implement changes;
  • Join forces with other districts, especially those who have had successes, to share how to solve challenges; and
  • Start a task to move forward with implementing AI, which will help free up teacher administrative tasks and reduce burnout.

To download a copy of the executive summary, visit EAB's "The Voice of the Superintendent" survey page.

About the Author

Kate Lucariello is a former newspaper editor, EAST Lab high school teacher and college English teacher.

Featured

  • depiction of a K-12 classroom with geometric shapes forming students and a teacher, surrounded by multiple holographic learning tools in various subjects

    I've Been in K-12 for Over 15 Years. Here Are Three Things We Need to Do to Integrate AI Now.

    When AI is deployed responsibly and equitably, the potential advantages of empowering more personalized learning, optimizing student engagement, uncovering gaps in education, automating routine tasks, and freeing up more time for effective teacher-student interactions have the power to transform education.

  • computer with a red warning icon on its screen, surrounded by digital grids, glowing neural network patterns, and a holographic brain

    Report Highlights Security Concerns of Open Source AI

    In these days of rampant ransomware and other cybersecurity exploits, security is paramount to both proprietary and open source AI approaches — and here the open source movement might be susceptible to some inherent drawbacks, such as use of possibly insecure code from unknown sources.

  • futuristic AI interface with glowing data streams and abstract neural network patterns

    OpenAI Launches Its Largest AI Model Yet

    OpenAI has introduced GPT-4.5, its largest AI model to date, code-named Orion. The model, trained with more computing power and data than any previous OpenAI release, is available as a research preview to select users.

  • group of elementary school students designing video games on computers in a modern classroom with a teacher, depicted in a geometric and abstract style

    Using Video Game Design to Teach Literacy Skills

    The Max Schoenfeld School, a public school in the Bronx serving one of the poorest communities in the nation, is taking an innovative approach to improving student literacy.