Survey: AI Low on Superintendents' Priority List as Districts Face Challenges

  • By Kate Lucariello
  • 02/26/24

In education consulting company EAB's 2024 "The Voice of the Superintendent" survey, while superintendents agree that adopting AI is important, non-academic challenges make it a low priority.

The online survey, which ran from Nov. 27, 2023, to Jan. 10, 2024, was completed by 148 superintendents in 39 states. Of those completing, 70% had been in their jobs from one to 10 years. The majority of district makeup was suburban (52%) and rural (37%).

The survey reported an increase in superintendent job satisfaction, with a 9% increase in those planning to stay in their jobs over the next two years, despite exhaustion and burnout.

While 97% of superintendents feel schools should implement and teach the responsible use of AI in their classrooms, only 37% currently have a plan to do so. For the rest, non-academic challenges are making it nearly impossible.

Superintendents reported these major challenges have either stayed the same or increased since 2023:

  • Chronic student absenteeism, cited by 63% of respondents;
  • Disruptive student behaviors, 77%;
  • Worsening student mental health, 76%, with 77% of superintendents blaming social media (These first three challenges have been prevalent regardless of student socioeconomic status, results show.);
  • Chronic staff absenteeism, 51% instructional, and 52% non instructional (with working conditions to blame); and
  • Staffing shortages, i.e., open positions, 52% instructional and 66% non instructional.

The survey concludes with three major recommendations for addressing these issues:

  • Build a leadership team to identify solutions and implement changes;
  • Join forces with other districts, especially those who have had successes, to share how to solve challenges; and
  • Start a task to move forward with implementing AI, which will help free up teacher administrative tasks and reduce burnout.

To download a copy of the executive summary, visit EAB's "The Voice of the Superintendent" survey page.

About the Author

Kate Lucariello is a former newspaper editor, EAST Lab high school teacher and college English teacher.

Featured

  • AI toolbox containing a wrench, document icon, gears, and a network symbol

    Common Sense Media Releases Free AI Toolkit, AI Readiness & Implementation Guides

    Common Sense Media has developed an AI Toolkit for School Districts, available to educators free of charge, that provides guidelines and resources for implementing AI in education.

  • elementary school building with children outside, overlaid by a glowing data network and transparent graphs

    Toward a Holistic Approach to Data-Informed Decision-Making in Education

    With increasing access to data and powerful analytic tools, the temptation to reduce educational outcomes to mere numbers is strong. However, educational leadership demands a more holistic and thoughtful approach.

  • three silhouetted education technology leaders with thought bubbles containing AI-related icons

    Ed Tech Leaders Rank Generative AI as Top Tech Priority

    In a recent CoSN survey, an overwhelming majority of ed tech leaders (94%) said they see AI as having a positive impact on education. Respondents ranked generative AI as their top tech priority, with 80% reporting their districts have gen AI initiatives underway, or plan to in the current school year.

  • AI-powered individual working calmly on one side and a burnt-out person slumped over a laptop on the other

    AI's Productivity Gains Come at a Cost

    A recent academic study found that as companies adopt AI tools, they're not just streamlining workflows — they're piling on new demands. Researchers determined that "AI technostress" is driving burnout and disrupting personal lives, even as organizations hail productivity gains.