Report: States Need to Improve High School Accountability Systems

The Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA) has created an opportunity for states to overhaul their high school accountability systems, but most are not taking advantage of that opportunity, according to a new report from Fordham Institute.

The report, High Stakes for High Schoolers: State Accountability in the Age of ESSA, examines current or planned state accountability systems for high schools. In particular, the report evaluates whether those systems consider the needs of high-achieving students and ways that states can redesign their accountability systems to better serve all students.

Most states focus on student proficiency rates, which measure the proportion of students who achieve the "proficient" level on state assessments, according to the report, and this approach is flawed because it closely correlates with student demographics and prior achievement and does not indicate which schools are actually effective at promoting growth in student achievement.

According to the report, "states can and should take four steps to ensure that the needs of high achievers are prioritized under ESSA," and it evaluated each state on each of these four indicators:

  1. Does the state rate high schools’ academic achievement using a model that gives additional credit for students achieving at an advanced level?
  2. Does the state rate high schools’ growth using a model that includes the progress of all individual students, not just those below the "proficient" line?
  3. When calculating summative high school ratings, does the state assign at least as much weight to "growth for all students" as it does to achievement?
  4. Does the state rate high schools’ success in helping students earn college credit before graduating via AP, IB, and/or dual-enrollment programs?

The report rated state accountability systems based on the most recent publicly available information. It identified only four states — Georgia, Ohio, Pennsylvania and Texas — with current accountability systems that met all four of the Fordham Institute's evaluation criteria, and four others – Alabama, Idaho, Louisiana and New York — that are "moving in the right direction."

Other key findings from the report:

  • 32 states include high achieving students in their evaluation of academic growth;
  • 21 states value "growth of all students" as much as student achievement;
  • 21 states rate success at helping students earn college credit before graduation; and
  • 16 states and the District of Columbia assign additional credit for high-achieving students.

A previous report from the Fordham Institute, High Stakes for High Achievers: State Accountability in the Age of ESSA, evaluated state accountability systems for K-8 schools.

The latest report, "High Stakes for High Schoolers: State Accountability in the Age of ESSA," can be found on the Fordham Institute's site.

About the Author

Leila Meyer is a technology writer based in British Columbia. She can be reached at [email protected].

Featured

  • students using digital devices, surrounded by abstract AI motifs and soft geometric design

    Ed Tech Startup Kira Launches AI-Native Learning Platform

    A new K-12 learning platform aims to bring personalized education to every student. Kira, one of the latest ed tech ventures from Andrew Ng, former director of Stanford's AI Lab and co-founder of Coursera and DeepLearning.AI, "integrates artificial intelligence directly into every educational workflow — from lesson planning and instruction to grading, intervention, and reporting," according to a news announcement.

  • toolbox featuring a circuit-like AI symbol and containing a screwdriver, wrench, and hammer

    Microsoft Launches AI Tools for Educators

    Microsoft has introduced a variety of AI tools aimed at helping educators develop personalized learning experiences for their students, create content more efficiently, and increase student engagement.

  • laptop displaying a red padlock icon sits on a wooden desk with a digital network interface background

    Reports Point to Domain Controllers as Prime Ransomware Targets

    A recent report from Microsoft reinforces warns of the critical role Active Directory (AD) domain controllers play in large-scale ransomware attacks, aligning with U.S. government advisories on the persistent threat of AD compromise.

  • Two hands shaking in the center with subtle technology icons, graphs, binary code, and a padlock in the dark blue background

    Two Areas for K-12 Schools to Assess for When to Work with a Managed Services Provider

    The complexity of today’s IT network infrastructure and increased cybersecurity risk are quickly moving beyond many school districts’ ability to manage on their own. But a new technology model, a partnership with a managed services provider, offers a way forward for schools to overcome these challenges.