Research Finds Mostly White Ed Force Unready to Support Minority Students

  • By Dian Schaffhauser
  • 08/06/19

A new RAND report found that more than 80 percent of educators agreed that their training experiences were relevant and effective (82 percent for teachers and 91 percent for school leaders). These individuals came out of their training programs feeling "prepared" to lead a school or teach in a classroom. Also, the more field experience somebody had during the pre-service period, the more likely he or she was to consider that training effective.

Yet, 40 percent argued that their pre-service programs failed to prepare them to support the needs of black, Latinx or low-income students. And that sentiment was higher among white principals and teachers, who make up four in five U.S. educators. The majority of public-school students are now non-White.

However, the report noted, this "race-based" gap nearly disappeared among school leaders who said their pre-service training program did a good job of preparing them in this aspect of their work. That suggested to researchers that "well-structured pre-service programs" could make a difference in building white educators' awareness of equity issues and building their skill sets to support a diverse student body.

Another interesting note: Principals were far more likely than teachers to agree that they felt prepared to use data to "continuously improve" their schools (90 percent compared to 62 percent).

Along with increased focus on supporting the needs of a diverse student body, the report also suggested that educator preparation programs emphasize field experience and "high-quality mentorship experiences" that tie to the coursework.

The report was developed through a survey given to members of RAND's American Educator Panels at the behest of the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. The AEPs encompass both teachers (nearly 29,000) and principals (almost 13,000). This data was merged with other information pulled from the National Center for Education Statistics Common Core of Data for 2015-2016.

"Principal and Teacher Preparation to Support the Needs of Diverse Students" is openly available on the RAND website.

About the Author

Dian Schaffhauser is a former senior contributing editor for 1105 Media's education publications THE Journal, Campus Technology and Spaces4Learning.

Featured

  • AI symbol racing a padlock symbol on a red running track

    AI Surpasses Cybersecurity in State Education Leader Priority List

    For the first time, artificial intelligence has moved to the top of the priority list for state education leaders — knocking cybersecurity from the number one spot, according to the 2025 State EdTech Trends report from SETDA.

  • stack of gold coins disintegrates into digital particles against a dark circuit-board background with glowing AI imagery

    Report: Most Organizations See No Business Return on Gen AI Investments

    Despite $30-40 billion in enterprise spending on generative AI, 95% of organizations are seeing no business return, according to a recent report out of the MIT Media Lab.

  • robot brain with various technology and business icons

    Google Cloud Study: Early Agentic AI Adopters See Better ROI

    Google Cloud has released its second annual ROI of AI study, finding that 52% of enterprise organizations now deploy AI agents in production environments. The comprehensive survey of 3,466 senior leaders across 24 countries highlights the emergence of a distinct group of "agentic AI early adopters" who are achieving measurably higher returns on their AI investments.

  • student reading a book with a brain, a protective hand, a computer monitor showing education icons, gears, and leaves

    4 Steps to Responsible AI Implementation in Education

    Researchers at the University of Kansas Center for Innovation, Design & Digital Learning (CIDDL) have published a new framework for the responsible implementation of artificial intelligence at all levels of education, from preschool through higher education.