States Seeing Improved Public Charter School Laws

An advocate for public charter schools has released its annual ranking of state school laws. Its big finding: Those states with new or overhauled laws regulating public charters are "bypassing" states that were previously ranked higher in multiple areas, including accountability, flexibility and funding equity.

The National Alliance for Public Charter Schools said the latest round of school laws affecting charters are coming closer to what it considers a "gold standard," its own "model public charter school law," which the organization published in 2016.

The Alliance's index examines 21 categories of what it calls "essential components of strong public charter school law." These include whether the state puts caps on the number of charters it will allow, who may authorize the schools, how those authorizers and the schools are funded, how enrollment lottery procedures are handled, what special education responsibilities are, whether collective bargaining is required or exempted and how exempt the schools are from other state or district laws regulating public education. Each of the 21 areas is given a weighting between one and four points, and each state's law on charters is rated. The total score determines where in the ranking a state appears.

Indiana showed up first on the list, as it has for the previous three years as well. As a report on the findings noted, "Indiana's law does not cap charter school growth, includes multiple authorizers and provides a fair amount of autonomy and accountability." At the same time, there's still work "to be done" in Indiana, particularly in filling the funding gap that the Alliance said the state has created between charter school students and their counterparts in district public schools. Another area that needs attention, the report pointed out, was in "strengthening accountability for full-time virtual charter schools."

At the bottom of the list is Maryland, which requires only district authorizers to charter new schools and offers "insufficient accountability and inequitable funding" for charters.

Georgia made the biggest leap in this year's rankings, moving up 11 spots from No. 27 to No. 16. The rise was credited to new regulations that address state policies on special education, funding and full-time virtual charter schools. Georgia's charter school law doesn't cap school growth for charters; lets multiple authorizers charter school applicants; and has "made notable strides" to provide "more equitable funding" to charter schools.

New York experienced the largest drop in the rankings, due to an existing cap on the creation of new charter schools, which leaves "precious little room for growth."

In many cases, states with new or overhauled laws are bypassing those states that were previously ranked higher, not because the existing leaders have weakened their regs, the Alliance suggested, but because charter school laws "are getting better across the board."

"As the report shows, many states are improving the quality of their charter school laws," said National Alliance President and CEO, Nina Rees, in a statement. "At the same time, we recognize that until every state has a high-quality law — and every student who wants to attend a charter school is able to — our work is not done."

The complete report is openly available on the Alliance's website.

About the Author

Dian Schaffhauser is a former senior contributing editor for 1105 Media's education publications THE Journal, Campus Technology and Spaces4Learning.

Featured

  • digital illustration of Estonia with glowing neural network-like connections spreading across the map

    Estonia to Roll Out ChatGPT Edu for all Secondary Schools

    In a nationwide artificial intelligence program dubbed "AI Leap 2025," the country of Estonia plans to provide free access to leading AI applications for all secondary school students and teachers. The initiative will launch with a rollout of ChatGPT Edu to 20,000 high school students in grades 10-11 and their 3,000 teachers, beginning Sept. 1.

  • computer monitor with glowing digital data and graphs bursting out in an abstract, energetic explosion of lines and elements against a dark background

    New OpenAI Agent Turns ChatGPT into a Research Analyst

    OpenAI has unveiled a new "Deep Research" feature that enhances ChatGPT with the capabilities of a "research analyst" that automates time-consuming research by retrieving, analyzing, and synthesizing online information.

  • glowing digital brain made of blue circuitry hovers above multiple stylized clouds of interconnected network nodes against a dark, futuristic background

    Report: 85% of Organizations Are Leveraging AI

    Eighty-five percent of organizations today are utilizing some form of AI, according to the latest State of AI in the Cloud 2025 report from Wiz. While AI's role in innovation and disruption continues to expand, security vulnerabilities and governance challenges remain pressing concerns.

  • blue and green lines intersecting and merging in an abstract pattern against a light gray background with a subtle grid design

    Gartner on Data Integration Market: Cloud Giants Down, AI Up

    "By 2027, AI assistants and AI-enhanced workflows incorporated into data integration tools will reduce manual intervention by 60 percent and enable self-service data management," according to Gartner.