We Must Teach Students How to Spot Misinformation: Teaching Digital Literacy Is Critical for K–12 Classrooms
I often see information that makes me wonder if what I'm seeing is true. Or sometimes I just believe it's true because it fits with my personal beliefs. I found myself in that situation during the most recent bout of Los Angeles wildfires: Reading wildly different takes and seeing some outrageous claims being made, I knew enough to know I needed to dig further to tease out some truth. But imagine being a child or teen, who has far less life experience. Would they even stop to ponder whether what they are hearing is accurate, or would they assume that since it's publicly available, it must be true?
This is the situation facing our country as a whole, every day, all day. Learning how to question and analyze are skills that must be honed and practiced. The education field is strongly positioned to support families in developing these key skills in students. Educators must help train minds to look for flawed arguments, misuse of data, or outright lies so we can ensure that as students form their own thoughts on issues, they are grounding them in reality.
The Impact of Digital Content
Misinformation isn't new. Yellow journalism has been around as long as newspapers have existed. Lies have a long history as well. Historical events like the Salem Witch Hunt are proof of that. The situation has grown worse, though, with the advent of digital information. Internet and social media sites have made information, including misinformation, very accessible to both consumers and creators. According to the National Household Education Surveys Program conducted by the National Center for Educational Statistics, almost all students have a way to access the internet, regardless of factors such as race and economic status. There are some positive consequences associated with that data. Having more information can lead to students researching topics more deeply or going down rabbit holes that pique their interest. They get to read differing opinions and access data much more easily than in the past. But there are also huge risks that the information they are accessing is inaccurate.
Consider this: Currently, there are over two hundred million active websites, many of which are not screened for accuracy. The most popular website for kids is YouTube. I use YouTube all the time. But what users get is hit or miss in regard to the quality of information. After all, an individual doesn't need to show proof of expertise to post. The second most used site is Google. Think of all those searches kids do, for homework or just for personal interest. Who is vetting those sources? And how many students are using AI without understanding that it pulls from what is available, which includes potentially flawed or biased sources? Much of this information is accessed at school or as part of a homework assignment. All of this explains why it is imperative for educators to play a role in preparing students to question and evaluate before just consuming information as fact.
Integrating Fact Checking Organically
Educators already have so much to juggle. But helping students recognize misinformation can be woven into lessons naturally. Start small by examining a current topic and discussing whether the information is factual or influenced by opinion, persuasive language, or missing evidence. Encourage students to use common sense and investigate claims that seem unreasonable through observation or simple experiments. Older students should research original sources, consider author bias or sponsorship, and verify information across multiple reliable sources to build critical evaluation skills.
If educators decide to do a targeted lesson on the ability to discern misinformation, there are some helpful websites that exist that could be integrated into lesson plans. The News Literacy Project is a non-partisan organization that provides free lessons and strategies to help teachers navigate the misinformation space with their students. Another example is the website www.allaboutexplorers.com. This site uses fictitious biographies of famous explorers to help students understand that even though something looks official, it can still be inaccurate. Teachers can then work with students to identify questionable information and find more reliable sources.
Helping students swim through the sea of information is critical to building fully informed citizens capable of making up their own minds because they are equipped with the skills to identify misinformation. Let's equip students to be savvy consumers of information as part of their educational journey.
About the Author
Laura Hansen is a former educator who currently serves as vice president, product assessments, for NWEA, a division of HMH.